Kosky, Balmer, Keat and Wise: Exploring Engineering, Fourth Edition, Solution Manual, Chapter 4
a) Take to
another
company
b) Initiate
patent search
c) Talk to
boss’
supervisor
d) Complain
to human
resources
Hold
paramount the
safety, health
and welfare of
the public.
Perform
services only
in the area of
your
competence
Issue public
statements
only in an
objective and
truthful
manner
Act for each
employer or
client as
faithful agents
or trustees
No, unless
there is other
evidence for
poor
performance
by your boss
No, without
your
company’s
permission
No, without
company’s
permission
Yes, unless
you lie about
the boss’
performance
Conduct
themselves
honorably …
No, you are
probably
reacting
personally
instead of
professionally
Solution: There is ethical tension here. Canons 1 and 6 imply that you should pursue your
idea for the public benefit. Canons 4 and 5 imply that you should not pursue your idea in a
way that violates the legal and ethical obligations you have assumed as a condition of
employment. The four options presented offer no way out of this impasse. This suggests
that the correct answer is “none of the above.” You should explore other options that
fulfill your duties to both your employer and the public. These might range, for example,
from informing your supervisor that you are going to pursue the idea through company
channels to quitting your job, waiting the required legal interval, and then pursuing the
idea on your own.