11-25) You now have an entry level position as an engineer at a hand tool manufacturing
company. You are put on a team of engineers that is about to release the design of a new battery
powered screw driver to manufacturing. By handling the prototype you notice that the screw
driver has a heavy battery and that the direction that the shaft turns is activated by the user
twisting his/her wrist at a severe angle. You point this out at a team meeting and suggest that the
design may have serious ergonomic problems that could result in user wrist injury during long
term use. The team quietly listens to your comment and replies that profit, not user ergonomics,
is their goal. What do you do? (Use the Engineering Ethics Matrix.)
a) Reassert your position by suggesting that customer satisfaction will also lead to profits.
b) Contact the company lawyer as a whistle blower about a possible dangerous product.
c) Talk to the team leader in private and suggest an ergonomics expert be added to the team.
d) Send an anonymous email to the company president warning him/her about possible law
suits.
Solution: There are no unique solutions to these scenarios. The student’s responses can be talking points
in class.