Fluid Mechanics, 6th Ed. Kundu, Cohen, and Dowling
Exercise 7.44. The flow-field produced by suction flow into
a round vacuum cleaner nozzle held above a large flat
surface can be easily investigated with a simple experiment,
and analyzed via potential flow in (R,
ϕ
, z)-cylindrical
coordinates with the method of images.
a) Do the experiment first. Obtain a vacuum cleaner that has
a hose for attachments. Remove any cleaning attachments
(brush, wand, etc) or unplug the hose from the cleaning
head, and attach an extension hose or something with a
round opening (~4 cm diameter is recommended). Find a
smooth dry flat horizontal surface that is a ~0.5 meter or
more in diameter. Sprinkle the central 1/3 of the surface
with a light granular material that is easy to see (granulated sugar, dry coffee grounds, salt, flour,
talcum powder, etc. should work well). The grains should be 1/2 to 1 mm apart on average. Turn
on the vacuum cleaner and lower the vacuum hose opening from ~0.25 meter above the surface
toward the surface with the vacuum opening facing toward the surface. When the hose gets to
within about one opening diameter of the surface or so, the granular material should start to
move. Once the granular material starts moving, hold the hose opening at the same height or lift
the hose slightly so that grains are not sucked into it. If many grains are vacuumed up, distribute
new ones in the bare spot(s) and start over. Once the correct hose-opening-to-surface distance is
achieved, hold the hose steady and let the suction airflow of the vacuum cleaner scour a pattern
into the distributed granular material. Describe the shape of the final pattern, and measure any
relevant dimensions.
Now see if ideal flow theory can explain the pattern observed in part a). As a first
approximation, the flow field near the hose inlet can be modeled as a sink (a source with strength
–Q) above an infinite flat boundary since the vacuum cleaner outlet (a source with strength +Q)
is likely to be far enough away to be ignored. Denote the fluid density by
ρ
, the pressure far
away by p∞, and the pressure on the flat surface by p(R). The potential for this flow field will be
the sum of two terms:
b) Sketch the streamlines in the y–z plane for z > 0.
c) Determine K(R,z).
d) Use dimensional analysis to determine how p(R) – p∞ must depend on
ρ
, Q, R, and h.
e) Compute p(R) – p∞ from the steady Bernoulli equation. Is this pressure distribution consistent
with the results of part a)? Where is the lowest pressure? (This is also the location of the highest
speed surface flow). Is a grain at the origin of coordinates the one most likely to be picked up by
the vacuum cleaner?
Solution 7.44. a) The pattern scoured in the granular material is axisymmetric. The scoured
region is a ring that is a little larger than the vacuum cleaner opening. A pile of the granular
material is left directly below the center of the vacuum cleaner opening.