exchange, a trade-in allowance is received on the old asset and the
balance is paid in cash. Accounting for the exchange depends on
whether the transaction has commercial substance. An exchange has
commercial substance if the company’s future cash flows change as a
result of the transaction. If an asset exchange has commercial
substance, a gain or loss is recorded based on the difference between
the book value of the asset given up and the market value of the asset
received. If an asset exchange lacks commercial substance, no gain or
loss is recorded, and the asset received is recorded based on book
value of the asset given up.
A. Exchange with Commercial Substance: A Loss
When the book value of the assets given up (cash paid plus book
value of the old equipment) is more than the market value of the
equipment received, a loss is recorded. Entry: debit the new
equipment for market value, debit Loss on Exchange of Assets
(difference between the book value of the assets given up and the
market value of the new asset), debit Accumulated Depreciation
for the old equipment, credit Equipment (old) for cost of the old
equipment, credit cash for the cash paid.
B. Exchange with Commercial Substance: A Gain
When the market value of the equipment received is more than
the book value of the assets given up (cash paid plus book value
of the old equipment), a gain is recorded. Entry: debit the new
equipment for market value, debit Accumulated Depreciation for
the old equipment, credit Equipment (old) for cost of the old
equipment, credit cash for the cash paid, and credit Gain on
Exchange of Assets for the gain (difference between market value
of the new asset and the book value of the assets given up).
C. Exchange without Commercial Substance
If the transaction lacks commercial substance, any gain or loss
which would have been recorded when the transaction had
commercial substance is not recorded. The unrecognized gain is
subtracted from the new asset’s market value to determine its cost
basis. The cost basis of the new asset also can be computed by
summing the book values of the assets given up.