5-16
term debt to assets ratio is generally less than 1, the result of
capitalizing leases will be to increase the long-term debt to assets
ratio.
Requirement 2:
A firm’s creditworthiness represents its ability to repay its obligations
on a timely basis. Any information relevant to assessing that ability
perform a “constructive capitalization” of operating leases when
assessing a firm’s creditworthiness. This procedure bases
measures of debt on a pro forma basis, as if the operating leases
had been capitalized.
Standard and Poor’s describes the reasons it constructively
operating lease adjustment therefore seeks to capitalize all
leases, thereby:
enhancing comparability of operating and financial results
and financial obligations among companies that lease assets
under leases accounted for as operating or financing leases,
significant investment in fixed assets, Company A has the slowest
total asset turnover. Company C has a faster asset turnover ratio
P510 Determining profitability
Note to the instructor: The following preliminary calculations provide
needed data for the remainder of the problem.
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Average assets = (Beginning assets
+ ending assets)/2
$3,725,818
$3,740,568
$4,070,175
Average common stockholders’
equity = (Beginning equity + ending
equity)/2
2,196,600
2,166,206
2,262,225
EBI = net income + (interest x
(1– tax rate))
325,051
126,822
178,214
Requirement 1:
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
ROA (EBI/Average assets)
0.087
0.034
0.044
Operating profit margin (EBI/Sales)
0.068
0.029
0.037
Asset turnover (Sales/Average assets)
1.28
1.16
1.18
Requirement 2:
Nucor experienced a substantial ROA decline from Year 2 to Year
3. ROA rebounded slightly in Year 4, but was still significantly below
Year 2 levels. While some of this decline was attributable to slowing
Year 2
Year 3
5-18
Note to the instructor: Nucor had no preferred stock outstanding
during Year 1 to Year 4. The company did not report any
restructuring or other non-operating charges.
P511 Business strategy and profit performance
Requirement 1:
Tiffany pursues a classic differentiation strategy: the particular
luxury items sold by Tiffany are simply not available elsewhere.
$1.18 at Signet. This comparatively low asset turnover rate is
consistent with a Tiffany’s strategy of differentiation built around
from 0.84, sales must be have increased by 40.5% (1.18 / 0.84
5-19
1.18).
P512 Blockbuster Inc.
Requirement 1:
Cash used for investing activities is a positive number when the firm
raises more cash from investment sales than it uses for new
The company must make sizable debt payments in each of the next
five years, but it has only generated modest cash from operations
5-20
Daley’s current liabilities are increased by the declaration of a cash
dividend. So, this transaction would reduce the current ratio.
Inventory and cost of goods sold are unaffected, so the inventory
turnover ratio is unchanged. Similarly, long-term debt and total
assets are unchanged, so the long-term debt to total assets ratio is
current assets. So, the current ratio falls. The decline in cost of
goods sold, together with the increase in inventory, causes
inventory turnover to fall as well. Because current assets fall, total
assets also fall, so the ratio of long-term debt to total assets
increases.
so there is no change to either of those ratios.
Requirement 4:
Current assets increase, so the current ratio increases. There is no
change in inventory turnover. Because a loss is recorded, the
insurance receivable must be less than the book value of the assets
P514 Explaining changes in financial ratios
(AICPA adapted)
1) a,b,d Inventory turnover is defined as the cost of goods sold
5-21
inventory, but in this case were mistakenly recorded as sales and
removed from inventory. Credit memos were not recorded for
2) a,b,e Accounts receivable turnover is net credit sales divided by
average accounts receivable. Recording goods shipped on
consignment before they are actually sold overstates accounts
3) a,b,e If the allowance for doubtful accounts increased in dollars,
but the allowance decreased as a percentage of accounts
4) p The refinancing of short-term debt as long-term debt at a
5) l,p Net income for the year can be found from operating income
less interest expenses and federal income taxes. If operating
6) h Gross margin percentage is defined as gross margin divided
margin is Sales less cost of goods sold, then cost of goods sold
must have also increased by the same proportionate amount.
P515 EBITDA and revenue recognition
Requirement 1:
collection period, which rebounds in 2014, but is still significantly
weaker than in 2012. There has also been a noticeable shift in the
composition of receivables (“billed” versus “unbilled”).
Receivable Composition 2012 2013 2014
2012 2013 2014
EBIT $74.8 $75.8 $38.1
Depreciation and amortization $14.8 $15.4 $19.3
5-23
One reason for the increase in days accounts receivable
outstanding is that the percentage of “unbilled” receivables has
increased. Customers do pay unless they are billed!
Requirement 4:
P516 Analyzing ratios: Alpine Chemical
(CFA adapted)
Requirement 1:
1,629 + 318
5-24
(Net income + Depreciation expense)/(Long-term debt + Notes
payable)
=
(1,479 + 511)
(1,900 + 1,491) =59%
d) Operating income/sales =
2,458 =13%
19,460
b) Longterm debt/total capitalization measures Alpine’s financial
leverage. A highly leveraged company can find that issuing new
debt is difficult or expensive. Also, a highly leveraged company is
more sensitive to a business downturn.
c) Funds from operations/total debt measures Alpine’s ability to
costs
reduced, to generate the same level of operating income. If Alpine
cannot
raise sales volume or reduce costs, then its ability to issue new debt
without adversely affecting current debt holders is limited.
Requirement 3:
a) EBIT/interest expense. With the exception of 2010, interest
5-25
c) Funds from operations/total debt. The cash flow ratio has been
relatively steady during the past three years and, at 59% in 2014,
would reflect a rating between A and Aa.
P517 Determining reportable segments
Requirement 1:
U.S. GAAP requires companies to provide segment information to
make investors and creditors aware of the different operating
similar economic characteristics, products, processes, customers,