Question Accounting Information Analysis & Decision
How much did the
company pay in
cash dividends?
Statement of
stockholders’ equity
The statement of stockholders’
equity provides a summary of
the activity in each equity
account during the period. Any
dividends declared and paid
during the year will be reported
in this statement.
Question Accounting Information Analysis & Decision
Do investors
expect future
earnings to grow?
Price-earnings ratio (PE
ratio)
A high PE ratio indicates
investors expect future
earnings to be higher. A low PE
ratio indicates investors’ lack
of confidence in future
earnings growth.
Ethical Dilemma
Ethical Dilemma
Intercontinental Clothing Distributors has paid cash dividends every year since the company was
founded in 1990. The dividends have steadily increased from $0.05 per share to the latest
dividend declaration of $1.00 per share. The board of directors is eager to continue this trend
despite the fact that earnings fell significantly during the recent quarter as a result of worsening
economic conditions and increased competition. The chair of the board proposes a solution. He
suggests a 5% stock dividend in lieu of a cash dividend, to be accompanied by the following
press announcement: “In place of our regular $1.00 per share cash dividend, Intercontinental will
distribute a 5% stock dividend on its common shares, currently trading at $20 per share.
Changing the form of the dividend will permit the company to direct available cash resources to
the modernization of facilities and other capital improvements.
Is a 5% stock dividend on shares trading at $20 per share equivalent to a $1.00 per share cash
dividend? Is the chair’s suggestion ethical?
Key issues
Is a stock dividend equivalent to a cash dividend?
Is the chair of the board ethical in replacing the cash dividend with a stock dividend?
Option 1: Replace the cash dividend with a stock dividend
Replacing the cash dividend with a stock dividend frees up available cash.
Intercontinental is able to replace a significant cost to the company in the form of cash
dividends with a stock dividend that essentially costs the company nothing at all.
Announcing a stock dividend in place of the cash dividend may be better received than
having to announce a decrease in or the complete elimination of cash dividends.