7. Ross Perot, a former Presidential candidate of the Reform Party, which was a third political
party in the United States, had strongly objected to the creation of the North American Trade
Agreement (NAFTA), which nonetheless was inaugurated in 1994. Perot feared the loss of
American jobs to Mexico where it is much cheaper to hire workers. What are the merits and
demerits of Perot’s position on NAFTA? Considering the recent economic developments in
North America, how would you assess Perot’s position on NAFTA?
Answer: Since the inception of NAFTA, many American companies indeed have invested
heavily in Mexico, sometimes relocating production from the United States to Mexico. Although
this might have temporarily caused unemployment of some American workers, they were
8. In 1995, a working group of French chief executive officers was set up by the Confederation
of French Industry (CNPF) and the French Association of Private Companies (AFEP) to study
the French corporate governance structure. The group reported the following, among other
things: “The board of directors should not simply aim at maximizing share values as in the U.K.
and the U.S. Rather, its goal should be to serve the company, whose interests should be clearly
distinguished from those of its shareholders, employees, creditors, suppliers and clients but still
equated with their general common interest, which is to safeguard the prosperity and continuity
of the company”. Evaluate the above recommendation of the working group.
Answer: The recommendations of the French working group clearly show that shareholder
wealth maximization is not a universally accepted goal of corporate management, especially
9. Emphasizing the importance of voluntary compliance, as opposed to enforcement, in the
aftermath of such corporate scandals as those involving Enron and WorldCom, U.S. President