1. What does Takaki mean by “a different mirror”?
2. According to Takaki, what is the dominant view of America’s racial history?
3. Briefly describe the experiences and contributions of African Americans, Asian Americans,
Chicanos, Irish, Jews, and American Indians as racial and ethnic groups with in the United
States.
4. Identify similarities and differences in the experiences of African Americans, Asian
Americans, Chicanos, Irish, Jews, and American Indians.
5. According to Takaki, what is the benefit in understanding the history of racial and ethnic
groups within the United States?
Internet Sites and Questions for Further Study:
Numbers USA
1. According to this organization, what is the future of immigration?
2. How is this point of view reflected in the history and influence of previous immigrant
groups?
1. Describe a few of the issues presented regarding immigration.
3. “The First Americans: Americans Indians,” Matthew Snipp
Matthew Snipp presents a historical summary of the United States’ treatment of American
Indians: removal, assimilation, the Indian New Deal, termination and relocation, and self
determination. In the early 1800s removal of American Indians was the goal of the United
States. Increased population and newly acquired land encouraged the push of American Indians
westward, first through negotiated treaties and ultimately through forced removal. These actions
resulted in severe hardship for American Indians physically and culturally. At the end of the
1800s the government policy regarding American Indians shifted to assimilation, or rather
“humane extinction.” The goal of the government, Snipp points out was to “civilize” American
Indians through religion, education, ownership of property, and agricultural careers. The effect
of assimilation on American Indians was the loss and disorganization of land, the impact of
which is still being felt today.
In the early 1930s the government encompassed American Indians in the New Deal programs.
This shift in treatment demonstrated a new respect for American Indian culture and land.
Economic and infrastructure support was granted to American Indian reservations, and tribal
governance was allowed. American Indian policy took a different shift after WWII with the
goals of termination and relocation. The United States government sought to terminate their
dealing with American Indians and relocate American Indians to urban areas. In the era of the
Civil Rights movement, yet another shift in United States and American Indian relations
occurred. “Self–determination,” the goal of American Indian autonomy, became the focus
resulting in greater control of tribal governments and the end to termination policies. Snipp
concludes with a discussion of the current status of American Indians. Population growth among
American Indians has increased on reservations and in Urban areas. Snipp points out that both
of these segments of the American Indian population face economic hardship. Urban American
Indians also face the struggle of maintaining their culture away from reservations. Pan-
Indianism has served to unite American Indian tribes in their fight for survival.