Under the Eighth Amendment punishments must be proportional or________to the
crime committed.
When a full body search is lawful, police might still be found to have gone too far. This
area of law is still being shaped. What limits do you think should be placed on these
searches? Do you think your standard adequately reflects the need for effective law
enforcement to be balanced with individual rights? Explain.
In 1994 80% of the US public supported capital punishment. In 2013, 63% of
Americans were in favor of the death penalty. A survey of police officers found that
94% favored the death penalty, with 96% of the police giving as the primary reason that
it removed a dangerous person from the population. Another reason given was that
capital punishment serves as a powerful deterrent to murder. In 2010, 88% of the
country’s top academic criminological societies rejected the notion that the death
penalty acts as a deterrent to murder. Do these statistics strongly support the argument
that capital punishment is inappropriate one in the United States today? Can you
suggest an alternate explanation for these statistics?