Historically, a great debate has focused on whether intelligence is a product of heredity
or a product of an individual’s environment. Using supporting evidence from the text,
argue one of these two points of view.
Elaine Hanley teaches at Maple Hills High School in a large suburban community. Her
third period advanced placement history students completed their first exam of the year
and they were not happy with the results.
Mrs. Hanley knew the students would be concerned. Most of them were applying at
competitive colleges across the nation, so grades and grade point averages were a part
of their daily discussions.
“I’m doomed!” cried a student who Mrs. Hanley knew was applying to Carlston
University, a prestigious nearby institution. “I’ll never get into Carlston now!”
“Mrs. Hanley, what can we do?” asked another member of the class. “I’m not sure it’s
worth taking this advanced placement class if all I can get is a C on the exam. I’d be
better off in the regular history class getting A’s.”
“Instead of changing classes,” declared Mrs. Hanley, “let’s figure out some study
strategies that will help you get high grades on my tests. First of all, what’s different
about my tests? Why are they more difficult for you?”
“You make us know the stuff. In most classes we just write down what the teacher says,
memorize it, then take the exam.”
Mrs. Hanley replied, “Well, you’re right, I want you to do more than memorize history.