You Make the CallSituation 1
When they created Round Table Group (RTG) Inc., Russ Rosenstein and Robert Hull
envisioned a company offering one-stop shopping for intellectual expertise. They
wanted to help businesspeople, management consultants, and litigation attorneys get
answers to important questions from topnotch thinkers anywhere in the world through
the Internet.
RTG’s plan was to have a kind of SWAT team of professors who would answer
questions based on their expertise. A team might consist of one or two professors, who
would communicate with the client via e-mail, phone, or videoconferencing on projects
that might involve a few hours or a few weeks of input. In the traditional
management-consulting model, work on a project often lasts as long as a couple of
years, and the team consists of a group of junior analysts, managers, and partners.
RTG assembled a database made up mainly of 3,000 university professors available to
consult on an as-needed basis. The firm’s fixed costs would be low because the
professors would be paid only when they did billable work. But an unexpected wrinkle
soon emerged. RTG’s customers wanted RTG to start acting more like a traditional
consulting firm. Business executives wanted face-to-face contact with the professors
giving the information. They also wanted number crunching and follow-up analysis.
And they wanted current, customized research.
That has left RTG at a crossroads. Should it try to become a more traditional
management-consulting firm or continue to pursue its original mission of providing
advice through Internet content and virtual links?
Taking the first path would mean providing support to clients, adding infrastructure and
formalizing its operation by dividing it into distinct specialties. That would have the
downside of making RTG’s competitive point of differentiation murky. But the second
path would risk putting off clients who say they want more.
Source: Elena De Lisser, “A Plan May Look Good, but Watch Out for the Real World,”
Startup Journal, The Wall Street Journal Online,
http://www.startupjournal.com/howto/management/199908240948-lisser.html, January
15, 2004.
Question 1 What is the basic problem that Rosenstein and Hull need to resolve?
Question 2 What are the advantages and disadvantages of the proposed online
consulting and the traditional approach to consulting?
Question 3 What do you think Rosenstein and Hull should do?