Case 9.1
Police stop Bill Stoner, a known drug dealer, for operating a vehicle with no tail lights,
after he is observed pulling away from a parking lot in a high crime area know for drug
transactions. Bill appears extremely nervous as he speaks with the officers. The primary
officer requests the registration and insurance card for the vehicle. As Sam opens the
glove box to retrieve the paperwork, the cover officer spots a hollow point bullets in the
glove box. She notifies her partner and Sam is immediately removed from the car and
frisked for possible weapons. The officer finds a loaded handgun in Bill’s waist band
and he placed under arrest. As the cover officer is securing the bullets, she notices Bill’s
cell phone on the front seat buzzing. She opens the phone and views multiple texts from
Donny Bosco warning Bill that “The cops are in the area get my bag of weed and coke
out of your trunk.” The officers secure Bill in the patrol car and search the trunk of
Bill’s car. In the trunk they find a large black duffle bag containing two pounds of
marijuana and two kilograms of cocaine.
Bill is transported back to headquarters and placed in an interrogation room. The
arresting officer shows the duffle bag full of drugs to Bill and tells him “you’re going
away for a long time unless you talk”. Bill is questioned about his association with
Donny Bosco and his part in the distribution of drugs. Bill completes and signs a
Miranda waiver form and then provides a videotaped confession in which he criminally
implicates Donny Bosco as the drug distribution leader. In addition to the charges
against Bill Stoner, Donny Bosco is indicted on several felony drug tracking charges.
On what grounds could the defense seek to exclude Bill’s videotaped confession?
a. Miranda
b. affirmative defense
c. writ of habeas corpus
d. inevitable discovery