B. SYMPOSIUM TWO: critique an art form (e.g., special effects in movies, black-
and-white photography, comic books, types of music videos, body-building,
body art, impressionist paintings, etc.). Research the history of the art form,
searching for specific criteria central to an evaluation of that form. Establish a list
of criteria for evaluating the chosen art form. Document the relevance of the
criteria by citing testimony of experts (see Appendix B of textbook for proper
form of citation). Explain the criteria, then as a group, choose “good,” “bad,” and
“mediocre” examples of the art form and justify the evaluation in terms of the
criteria.
1. Requirements: 5-minute speech per group member. Group time limit: 5
minutes times total number of members in group
2. Grading (100 total points):
40% group grade:
a. Organization: division of labor among participants is balanced; division
of topic into sub-categories is reasonable (10 points)
b. Content: criteria are carefully explained and well-supported with
evidence; evidence properly cited; criteria are applied effectively to
good, bad, and mediocre examples of art form (10 points) Attention:
effort is made to maintain interest and attention of audience throughout
symposium (10 points)
c. Quality of performance (style/delivery): use extemporaneous style of
presentation; no reading and no memorization (10 points).
60% individual grade:
a. Organization: signpost each speech and provide internal summaries;
clarity and comprehensibility are important (15 points)
b. Content: provide substance which contributes to the successful
evaluation of specific examples of the art form; exhibit research effort;
provide plentiful evidence supporting critique (15 points)
c. Attention: use attention strategies to maintain audience interest (15
points)
d. Style/delivery: use extemporaneous style; maintain eye contact; no
reading (15 points)
NOTE: The art form symposium exemplifies the importance of the criteria
step in the Standard Agenda group discussion technique (see Chapter 8 of
text). This is an excellent assignment for helping students learn how to
generate and apply criteria when tackling a problem. It is a sophisticated
learning experience requiring critical analytical skills.
II. Cooperative Examinations
Cooperative testing allows students to work together in a group (5 to 7 members) on
examination questions that check knowledge of key concepts and points presented in
the text. This is a unique approach to testing students. Study guides for each exam
will be distributed at least one week prior to the exam.
A. COOPERATIVE TEST #1: this test will cover the first three chapters of the
text. The format will be multiple-choice and true-false. Multiple-choice questions
will have four possible answers. You will choose all answers deemed correct