VIIII. Cooperative Exam FOUR Twelve Angry Men
Multiple-Choice
tried to ram his point of view down the other jurors throats.
(threatening, ridiculing, trying to win a contest, pressuring, insisting on their position
and no other).
was meaningful because the decision would free the defendant or send him to his
death; despite criticism and ridicule, every member was listened to because some
jurors always stepped in to insist each participant be heard. The jurors were
structurally interdependent because they couldn’t finish their task without consensus.
All jurors were held accountable for their positions and statements throughout the
deliberations. They continually had to justify their points of view and claims.
always involved so laissez-faire was never used by him, and he didn’t delegate any
responsibility to anyone—it wasn’t his place to do so.
is no seduction used (no bribe, etc.), he is ostracized (“You’re all alone”) by being
made to feel apart from the group; he is never coerced (threatened, ridiculed, etc.).
expertise, offers no scarce information, and does not hand out rewards.
jurors. There are also instances of empowerment such as when the old man (#9) is
encouraged to speak and he has impact on the discussion and decisions, and the jury
as a whole has the autonomy to decide the defendant’s fate; no one else will
intervene and make the decision.
baseball game than deliberating), was disrespectful to the old man and the architect,
and there was no real commitment to excellence—he made up his mind and didn’t
want to discuss the evidence at all.
sure the defendant was not guilty, but he wanted to examine the evidence (test the
strength of the case). He had one brief “fight” with juror #3 but this was fleeting and
hardly a primary role. He was always respectful of other jurors’ desire to contribute
so he wasn’t a stagehog, and he never had any particular zealous cause to impose on
other jurors except the main task—determine the innocence or guilt of the defendant.
other jurors (e.g., why would defendant go back and get the knife?). He was never an
isolate or a fighter-controller.
hypercompetitive (“I’m the competitive type”), says inappropriate things to fellow
jurors (“I’ll kill you,” “bunch of little old ladies”), and is Me-oriented throughout