CHAPTER 14 CRIMINAL LAW 213
30. Benji, a truck driver, is told by his boss, Penny, to quickly deliver a load of steel and to get to the
location within an hour regardless. Benji replied, “That’s impossible – I’d have to go 90 miles per
hour to do that.” Penny said, “Well, you’d best get started.” Not surprisingly, Benji was stopped by
a highway patrol officer and fined for both speeding and reckless driving. When he went to court,
Benji told the judge that he should be found innocent because he was only acting upon orders of his
boss, Penny. Is Benji correct?
A. Yes.
B. No.
C. Yes, but only if he can establish that he had a written contract obligating him to follow Penny’s
orders.
D. Yes, but only if he has no previous record of speeding.
31. Sherdon really wants to buy a new $40,000 boat, but lacks the funds with which to do so. He spends
some amount of time thinking about robbing the local bank. He casually mentions to his wife, Pearl,
that he has such thoughts. A few weeks later Pearl leaves Sherdon for the local mail carrier. Pearl
and Sherdon get in a dispute regarding splitting up their property. In a fit of anger, Pearl calls law
enforcement and informs on Sherdon for thinking about the bank robbery. The police arrest
Sherdon. Which of the following is the most likely result assuming Pearl is believed by a judge and
jury?
A. Sherdon should be released because he has committed no crime.
B. Sherdon should be found guilty of plotting to commit a felony..”
C. Sherdon should be found guilty of conspiracy.
D. Sherdon should be found guilty of the misdemeanor offense of “wrongful contemplation.”
32. Greg has too much to drink at a local bar. He yells out that Lynette, who was in the bar and had just
turned him down for a date, is loose with her affections and has even been guilty of stealing money
from the wallets of her dates. Those allegations are untrue. In fact, Lynette is a Sunday school
teacher who does not drink and was only in the bar accepting donations for a local charity. Lynette
promptly slaps him, and he pushes her away. Unfortunately for Greg, a police officer is present in
the bar and arrests Greg. Based on the altercation, Greg pays a hefty fine and spends 24 hours in jail
for violation of the jurisdiction’s criminal battery statute. The next week, Greg receives a civil
complaint filed by Lynette for defamation and a civil cause of action for battery. Greg says that he
already paid for the offense and that he should not be prosecuted twice. What should Greg do?
A. Greg should file a motion to dismiss Lynette’s suit which should be granted because of the bar
against double jeopardy.
B. Greg should file a motion to dismiss Lynette’s suit which should be granted because of the bar
against double jeopardy, and he should also sue Lynette for malicious prosecution.