E. There are no such laws
DUI Charge. Monique was licensed to train massage therapists. A new federal agency,
the Aesthetic and Massage Commission, took very seriously its role of enforcing the
statute enabling the Commission to do its work and providing that licensed massage
therapists must refrain from “any act or conduct indicating bad faith, incompetence,
dishonesty, or improper dealing.” Monique, while driving home late one night from a
party, was stopped by the police and arrested for driving under the influence of alcohol.
She pled guilty to the offense. When the Aesthetic and Massage Commission
discovered the offense, the officials of the agency met, decided that Monique might
drink on the job, and that she might pose a danger to students. Accordingly, her license
to teach massage therapy was revoked. Monique threatened to sue to retain her license
and was told by the agency head that she had no right to appeal to court because of the
nature of the Aesthetic and Massage Commission; and that, in any event, action by an
agency is always upheld. Which of the following is true regarding the statement by the
agency that assuming an appeal to court is available, agency action is always upheld?
A. The agency representative is essentially correct because agency decisions are upheld
in over 99% of the cases and may only be overturned if fraud on the part of the agency
is proven.
B. The agency representative is incorrect because agency decisions are usually struck
down unless they are supported by clear and convincing evidence.
C. The agency representative is incorrect because agency decisions are usually struck
down unless it can be established that an appeal of an agency decision is frivolous and
without reason.
D. The agency representative is incorrect because agency decisions are struck down in
approximately 50% of the cases on appeal.
E. The agency representative is incorrect because while agency actions are usually
upheld, they may be struck down if the agency, for example, exceeded its power.