Self-Centered President. Tina is the new president of “We Manage You,” a corporation
set up to manage physician practices. Tina has never been very concerned with minority
shareholders because she does not believe that they have any influence over the
company because they cannot even elect a director. She is told, however, that the
corporation has a practice of cumulative voting. An election is coming up in which 10
directors will be elected. Minority shareholders own 2,000 shares while majority
shareholders own 8,000 shares. Tina tells her vice president, George, that she wants to
ignore minority shareholders and focus her interests on majority shareholders and the
directors. She also tells George that she wants to be particularly conscientious toward
directors because the directors appoint officers, and she does not believe that she owes
any actual duties to shareholders. She further orders George to destroy some documents
subpoenaed in a criminal investigation against the company for illegal tax evasion.
When George protests, Tina tells him not to worry because officers cannot be held
responsible for criminal actions so long as the actions are done as part of the duties of
an officer. She explains to him that only the corporation can be charged with liability in
such cases. Is Tina accurate that she owes no duties to shareholders?
A. Yes, she is accurate because it is the directors who owe a duty to shareholders.
B. No, she is inaccurate because she owes a duty of care to shareholders although she
owes no other duties.
C. No, she is inaccurate because she owes a duty of loyalty to shareholders although she
owes no other duties.
D. No, she is inaccurate and owes both a duty of care and a duty of loyalty to
shareholders.
E. She is partially accurate. She owes both a duty of care and a duty of loyalty to
minority shareholders but no duties to majority shareholders because the law assumes
that they have the power to protect their own interests.
___________________ created the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board to
regulate public accounting firms.