C. Plaintiff files a lawsuit with the court.
D. Defendant files an answer.
E. Plaintiff is injured within the state’s border.
Insurance. Susan, a trained nurse, was recently elected to the U.S. Senate. Susan is very
concerned about the lack of insurance for many children and also working adults who
cannot afford the insurance premiums. She proposes legislation that states are taxed
sufficiently to provide health insurance coverage to children and that federal funds for
state highways are denied to any state that does not also provide insurance coverage for
uninsured adults. She also proposed that states with citizens earning higher than average
incomes be taxed at a higher rate than other states. Bill, a senator, tells Susan that
Congress lacks the authority to tax in this manner because the U.S. Constitution
expressly reserves that right to the states. Ellen, another senator, tells Susan that
Congress has no authority to link highway funds or any other funds with social welfare
objectives. Sam, an administrative assistant, tells Susan that Congress is prohibited
from taxing residents of one state at a higher rate than citizens of another state. Which
of the following is true regarding Sam’s statement?
A. Sam is incorrect. The U.S. Congress has complete discretion on taxation.
B. Sam is incorrect, but before the U.S. Congress taxes one state’s residents at a higher
rate than citizens of other states, a compelling need must be shown.
C. Sam is incorrect, but before the U.S. Congress taxes one state’s residents at a higher
rate than citizens of other states, an important need must be shown.
D. Sam is incorrect, but before the U.S. Congress taxes one state’s residents at a higher
rate than citizens of other states, a disparity of income of over 30% must be shown.
E. Sam is correct.