Book Payment. Molly and Pat signed a contract providing that “Pat will furnish the
correct used business law book for use in Molly’s business law class; and in return on
August 15, 2011, Molly promises to pay Pat $50 for the book.” Molly took the book
and planned to pay Pat. Meanwhile, Pat properly assigned the contract Molly had
signed to Jack. When Molly went to class, however, she discovered that the book was
the incorrect book. When Jack asked Molly for payment, Molly refused. Molly told
Jack that the book was useless to her and that she was not paying either him or Pat
anything for it. Jack told Molly that he had an enforceable assignment in the form of a
negotiable instrument and that he could collect regardless of whether the book was
useless. Molly did not believe him. Continuing with her attempt to save money on
books, Molly agreed to buy Tim’s U.S. history book for $40. She had an oral agreement
with Tim that he would give her the book and that she would pay him in three days.
This time Molly got the right book. Tim, in writing, properly assigned the right to the
$40 payment to Richard. Richard asked Molly for the money. Molly admitted her
agreement with Tim but told Richard that she was not going to pay him because he did
not have a negotiable instrument. Molly also purchased a communications book from
Sam promising in writing to give him in return the next day, to his order, a used DVD
player she owned. What is the effect of Molly agreeing to give Sam a DVD in return for
the book?
A. Molly and Sam have an enforceable contract, and Molly has also satisfied the
negotiability condition regarding the form of payment.
B. Because payment is not in a sum certain for money, Molly and Sam do not have an
enforceable contract nor does the agreement satisfy the negotiability requirement.
C. Molly and Sam have an enforceable contract, but the agreement fails to satisfy the
negotiability requirement that payment be in a sum certain in money.
D. Because payment is not in a sum certain for money, Molly and Sam do not have an
enforceable contract; but the requirement of negotiability regarding the form of
payment has been satisfied.
E. Unless Sam acknowledges in writing that the fair market value of the DVD is
equivalent to the value of the book he provided to Molly, there is no enforceable
contract nor is the agreement negotiable.