Neal is the young, likable, optimistic, and generous son of a prominent public official.
He has a master’s degree in business and is the business partner of Ken and Bill in an oil
drilling and exploration business. Neal also serves as a director on the board of the
Bonanza Savings and Loan Association. While serving on the Bonanza Board, Neal
votes to approve major loans to Ken and Bill without disclosing to the other directors
that he is a business partner of Ken and Bill. Neal also personally arranges for a
$900,000 line of credit from Bonanza for an oil drilling venture in which he is a partner
with Ken. The drilling venture is unsuccessful and Ken and Bill both default on their
loans to Bonanza, which then causes the S & L to become insolvent. Federal banking
officials, who then liquidate its assetsto pay its creditors and depositors, seize Bonanza.
Because Bonanza is federally insured, a substantial amount of tax money is also used to
pay off depositors whose deposits are insured under federal programs. Bonanza
shareholders lose their investment money. Was Neal’s conduct as a director of Bonanza
ethical? Analyze his conduct in light of the following ethical theories.
a. Intuitionism and the “Television Test.”
b. Milton Friedman’s ideas on corporate governance.
c. Deontological theories.
d. Rule utilitarianism.
e. Ethical relativism.