Check Cashing Business. Susan owns and operates a check cashing business. A
customer, Bob, claiming to be Sam, comes in and cashes a $2,000 check issued by ABC
Trucking to Sam. The day after Susan cashed the check, she received a notice from
ABC Trucking that some checks had been stolen. It was later discovered that the
customer had forged Sam’s name on the check issued by ABC Trucking. At the time she
took the ABC Trucking check, Susan was very busy with several customers in line. She
simply glanced at the check and cashed it. A reasonable examination would have
revealed that the check had been materially altered and changed from the amount of
$200 to $2,000. Susan decided that she needed to hire some people to help her because
she also had a problem with another check. On the same day that she took the ABC
Trucking check, she took a check from another customer, Maurice. It was later
discovered that the check from Maurice, which was four months old, was the subject of
a dispute between Maurice and the issuer of the check for whom Maurice had done
some work. The issuer claimed that the work was improperly done. Both ABC Trucking
and the issuer of the check to Maurice stopped payment on the checks. Susan claims
that she was entitled to the status of holder in due course and was entitled to payment
on both checks. What is the effect of Susan receiving notice the day after she cashed the
check for Bob that the check had been stolen?
A. The notice has no effect on her status as holder in due course because it was
provided after she cashed the check.
B. The notice prevents her from being a holder in due course.
C. The notice prevents her from being a holder in due course only if Bob had been
convicted of check cashing offenses in the past since she would have discovered his
history had she checked.
D. The notice prevents her from being a holder in due course only if she subjectively
knew that Bob had been charged criminally with check cashing violations in the past.
E. The notice prevents her from being a holder in due course because it was presented
to a business; only individuals can avoid the effect of notice of theft by cashing a check
prior to receiving notice.
The duration of one’s ownership interest and the power one has over using the land