“Machine Malfunction.” Bruno, the president of a health club operation called ABC
Health Club, convinced the board of directors to approve a large purchase of a type of
fitness machine called “Perfect Body.” Bruno had carefully investigated the machine
and did a presentation to the board on its purported benefits. Unfortunately, after the
purchase, it was announced that “Perfect Body” was actually a very dangerous machine
that should not be used. The manufacturer of “Perfect Body” went bankrupt, and ABC
lost $200,000 on the purchase of the machines. The shareholders are furious and want
to sue Bruno and the directors. In an attempt to appease her, the board of directors
agrees to allow Frances, the ring leader of the shareholders, to purchase stock of the
company at below its fair market value. Frances purchases a considerable amount of
stock on that basis, but says that the shareholders plan to continue with an action
against Bruno and the board members.
Which of the following is true regarding liability of Frances, if any, for purchasing the
stock at below its fair market value?
A. If the board wanted to offer it to her, they had that right, and there is no consequence
to Frances.
B. She is liable for double the stated corporate value of the stock in addition to any
price she already paid.
C. She is liable for the stated corporate value of the stock in addition to any price she
already paid.
D. She is liable for paying the difference between the price she paid for the shares and
the stated corporate value of the shares.
E. She is liable for paying the difference between the price she paid for the shares and
the stated corporate value of the shares plus a $10,000 penalty.