“Saturday Auction.” Barry, an auctioneer, held an auction on a Saturday morning. At the
beginning of the auction, Barry announced that the auction was being held without
reserve. Helen, Mary, and Chris were all in attendance. Helen saw an old cash register
with a stuck drawer that she thought would look great in her den. The auctioneer put the
cash register up for sale noting that the drawer was stuck but that it could probably be
fixed with little effort. Helen bought it for $20. When she got it home, she discovered
that it actually contained $5,000. Unfortunately, Helen had a teenage son named Tad
who started bragging to his friends about the family’s good fortune. Barry heard about
what had happened and sued Helen for return of the $5,000. At the same auction, Mary
saw a great deal on a used table. She bid $20 on it. No one else bid anything. Barry
announced that $20 was clearly insufficient for the table, that it was worth much more
than that, and that he was taking it out of the auction. Chris started bidding on a
diamond ring for his girlfriend. He bid $2,000. Just as Barry was getting ready to say
“Sold,” Chris looked over at his girlfriend, decided that he was not sure about marriage,
and leaped up yelling “I revoke.” Barry, however, immediately after, yelled “Sold.”
Barry sues Chris attempting to obtain the money for the engagement ring. Barry also
sues Helen seeking to recover the $5,000 contained in the stuck drawer. Mary sues
Barry attempting to obtain possession of the table.
In the lawsuit in which Barry sues Helen for return of the $5,000, which of the
following is the most likely result?
A. Barry will win because when an auction is held without reserve, the auctioneer is
entitled to repossess any item at will.
B. Barry will lose only because he was not the actual seller. He was only selling at
auction for someone else. The seller, however, would win in an action against Helen.
C. Barry would win because Helen made an insufficient offer.
D. Helen will win only if she can show that Barry had knowledge that cash was in the
drawer before he sold it.
E. Helen will win because the auction was without reserve, and she properly bid on and
bought the cash register with everyone knowing that the cash drawer was stuck.