“Horse Tracks.” Martha, Greg, and Prudence decided to form a corporation called
Horse Tracks to raise horses. They all began the corporate creation process by arranging
for necessary capital and financing. They raised capital from their friends by making
deals whereby their friends would purchase stock in the new corporation. After the
corporation was formed, a problem arose with a contract for feed that Martha, Greg,
and Prudence had entered into while organizing the corporation. Belinda, the seller of
the feed claimed that she had not been fully paid and threatened to sue the corporation.
The contract Martha, Greg, and Prudence had with Belinda did not reference liability
after the new corporation came into legal existence. Martha, Greg, and Prudence asked
for a novation, but were uncertain as to whether that would occur.
Which of the following is the most likely result if Belinda sues Martha, Greg, and
Prudence for unpaid amounts without a novation in place?
A. Belinda would likely win because courts generally hold promoters liable and rule
that preincorporation contracts do not bind the new corporation.
B. Belinda would likely win unless it can be established that the new corporation is
making a profit and is able to pay her.
C. Belinda would likely win unless it can be established that the new corporation was
capitalized with at least $100,000 and is able to pay her.
D. Martha, Greg, and Prudence will win so long as they can prove that Belinda knew
that the feed was purchased for a new corporation and not for their personal farm use.
E. Martha, Greg, and Prudence will win unless they have already paid partial amounts
leading Belinda to expect that they, not the corporation, had accepted liability.