Mike and Jill enter into a written contract for the lease of a car. Jill has leased cars from
Mike on two previous occasions. The lease states “the car may be driven for a
reasonable number of miles each year and there may be a surcharge for excessive
mileage.” At the end of the lease, which last for two years, Jill has put 100,000 miles on
the car. Mike charges Jill a surcharge and Jill refuses to pay because she does not
believe that 100,000 miles in two years is excessive. What will the Court consider first,
in determining what the lease meant by “reasonable number of miles”?
A) Any oral or written statements made by Mike or Jill regarding the meaning of
“reasonable number of miles.”
B) The fact that in the first year, Jill brought the car to Mike for an oil change, the car
had 60,000 miles at the time and Mike did not complain.
C) The fact that in the past Jill has driven the other leased cars for 100,000 miles
without being charged.
D) The fact that in the car leasing business, “reasonable number of miles” usually
means 30,000 miles a year.
E) The fact that Mike charges all of his customers a surcharge when they drive more
than 20,000 miles each year.
For Statute of Frauds purposes, an interest in land includes (but is not limited to):
A) fixtures.
B) mortgages.
C) insurance contracts on interests in land.