Contribution is the right of a co-obligator to demand that other obligator(s) pay their
fair share of the debt.
Al was a well-respected attorney in a small town. A couple retained Al to represent
them on the purchase of a home. Before closing, Al informed the couple of payments
that they were required to make by check at the closing. Among the required payments
the attorney told the couple to make were a check for $1,500 to Bob Brown and a check
for $610 to Susan Lee. The attorney explained that the check to Brown was for a survey
of the property and the check to Lee was for termite control work that the couple had
authorized.
The checks were issued and taken by Al who promised to deliver them. Al did not,
however, deliver them. Instead, Al forged the indorsements of the respective payees and
cashed the checks. When Al was later arrested on a similar matter, the couple learned
what had happened.
The couple made a claim against its bank for reimbursement, claiming the bank was not
authorized to pay these checks because they had not been effectively negotiated to the
bank. When the facts came to light, no person named Bob Brown had done a survey on
the property, but the termite work had been done by Lee. Decide both cases.