United States common law requires that case precedents be followed under all
circumstances.
A binding contract cannot contain a cancellation provision.
A professor owned a home next door to a very dilapidated, neglected home. John
Cataldo purchased the home next door and made a contract with Wizard Home
Improvements for a complete renovation of the property. The professor was delighted
because the improvement of the Cataldo home was upgrading the neighborhood and
raising the value of the professor’s home.
After making the last required payment on the contract, John Cataldo became seriously
ill and ultimately was taken to a nursing home for care.
When Wizard learned of Cataldo’s illness and confinement, Wizard ceased work on the
Cataldo home. Because the outside renovation work had not been completed, the
premises began to return to its former rundown condition. The professor ultimately sued
Wizard as a third-party beneficiary of the contract between Cataldo and Wizard. What
is the probable outcome of the lawsuit?