“Diving fiasco.” Mike, who owns a dive shop in the U.S., takes a group of his
customers diving in U.S. waters. Mike is aware that the area where the divers will be
visiting is occasionally visited by sharks. He is also aware that, while sting rays are
usually tame, they can become aggressive when fed. Mike did not reveal that
information to the group of divers going with him because in his experience, as soon as
customers hear of even a hint of danger, they refuse to pay and go on the trip. The
divers go down into the water, and some have squid with which to feed the sting rays.
During the dive, one of the sting rays becomes agitated and latches onto diver Susie’s
arm. Susie is so disconcerted that she drops her regulator (her breathing device) from
her mouth and is in considerable difficulty. Another diver, Billy, encounters a shark
which snaps at him. Fortunately, the shark does not bite him but does damage his diving
equipment. He is also in distress. Mike, who is in charge of the dive, does nothing but
return to the boat because the dive turned out to be more trouble than expected. Wendy,
another diver on the trip, also returns to the boat without doing anything to help the
divers in distress. Sam, on the other hand, goes to rescue the divers who are in distress.
He manages to assist them, but in the process, he pulls his back and requires medical
care. All divers return to the boat and are very unhappy with Mike.
Which of the following is true regarding whether Wendy and Sam had a duty to come to
the assistance of the divers in peril?
A. Neither Wendy nor Sam had a duty to go to the aid of the divers who were in peril.
B. Wendy and Sam had a duty to go to the aid of the divers in peril only if Mike refused
to do so.
C. Wendy and Sam did not have a duty to go to the aid of the divers in peril unless they
were the first to see the problem.
D. Wendy and Sam had a duty to assist the divers in peril only if they were acquainted
prior to the dive with the divers who were in peril. They had no duty to help strangers.
E. Sam and Wendy had a duty to help the divers who were in peril if personal safety
was involved but not if the only issue was damage to property.