Dogs and Formals. Paul owns a dog grooming business and needs patient people to
work there. He gives all applicants a test he obtained from a management firm that has
been proven to measure psychological traits such as patience. Penny alleges sex
discrimination after she fails the test miserably and Paul refuses to hire her. Paul tells
her that there is no way he is giving her a dime because he is entitled to protect his
client’s dogs. Upon learning that her state lacked a state office representing the Equal
Opportunity Commission, Penny immediately sues him in federal court alleging a
violation of Title VII. Paul, who is getting tired of the dog grooming business, also
opens a new formal wear shop and needs to hire employees there as well. He wants to
appeal to high school and college age young ladies attending proms and formals. Paul
decides that he does not want older sales clerks to assist in choosing formal dresses. He
only wants young, attractive ones. Paul runs an ad in the local paper-seeking applicants
for sales clerks and stating that a qualification for the job is computer training while in
high school. Tina, age 60, applies and tells Paul that while she sees no reason that
computer training should be required, she attended computer training in adult education
and has excellent computer as well as sales skills. Paul refuses to hire her telling her
that unless he follows the ad, he may be seen as practicing discrimination. Deciding that
formal wear is more trouble than dogs, Paul shuts down the formal wear store. Which
of the following is true regarding Penny’s action in federal court?
A. Her lawsuit was improperly filed because she did not first file with the federal Equal
Employment Opportunity Commission, and she lacked a right to sue letter.
B. Her lawsuit was improperly filed because she did not first insist on mediation.
C. Her lawsuit was improperly filed because she did not first insist on arbitration.
D. Her lawsuit was properly filed because her state had no state Equal Opportunity
Commission.
E. Her lawsuit was properly filed regardless of whether or not her state had a state
Equal Opportunity Commission.