Opponents of judicial review contend that judges have too much power, while
supporters believe there must be some watchdog to maintain the constitutionality of
law. Which position do you most agree with? Justify your answer and give examples of
recent cases or controversies that support your view.
Police officers can legally tell and impound vehicles for many reasons, including
vehicles involved in accidents, parked in a tow-away zone, or abandoned on the
highway. When the police impound a vehicle for legitimate reason, they may lawfully
conduct an inventory search. Assume a police officer lacks probable cause but has a
“gut feeling” that a known malcontent from the community has marijuana in the trunk
of his car. The police officer follows the malcontent until she fails to stop completely at
a stop sign. The police officer pulls over at the malcontent and, after asking for license
and registration, finds out (as she already suspected) that the malcontent has a
suspended license. The police officer arrests the malcontent and puts her in the backseat
of her police car. She then calls the local tow company to impound the vehicle for the
owner’s safety. The police officer is then happy to hear that during a normal inventory
inspection of the vehicle, marijuana is found and she promptly informs the district
attorney’s office. If the police officer has done nothing that violates the law or the
Fourth Amendment, can you articulate an argument that challenges what the police
officer did?