Zack said, “Wait a minute. I was only kidding.” Walter said, “No way.” Meanwhile all
the hula hoopers dropped out well prior to ten hours of hula hooping except for
Barbara. One minute before the ten hours were up, Walter yelled out “I revoke!”
Barbara completed the hula hooping anyway and asked for her car for $1,000. Walter
refused saying that the offer was revoked. Sam was very angry and sued Walter for not
having a car available that was under two years old so that he could get a good deal and
a $500 rebate. Additionally, Barbara sued Walter, and Walter sued Zack and Sally.
Which of the following is the likely result in the lawsuit brought by Sam complaining
that Walter ran out of cars available for a rebate?
A. Sam will win because Walter was required to have sufficient cars on hand for anyone
who requested one.
B. Sam will win because a rebate was involved.
C. Sam will win because Walter should have run another ad revoking the offer.
D. Sam will lose because he did not properly accept the offer.
E. Sam will lose because court would interpret the intent of Walter as being to invite
readers to make an offer that Walter was free to reject.
Marcy’s Mom. Marcy’s mother, Sue, did not want her to date until she was older. She
also wanted Marcy to attend law school. Just before Marcy started her freshman year in
college, Sue told Marcy that if Marcy would refrain from dating until she received her
law degree, then Sue would pay off all Marcy’s school loans and throw in an extra
$50,000. Marcy agrees and states, “Thanks, Mom, and by the way, when I graduate I’m
throwing you a big party for all you’ve done for me!” Sue smiles and hugs Marcy.
Marcy finished law school and asked for payment of her loans, the $50,000 in cash, and
for a car. Sue said, “No way – I know you went out on some dates during law school,
and I never agreed on the car.” Marcy said those were just study nights and that her
mother had never objected to Marcy’s frequent statements that she wanted a car upon
graduation. Sue asks about the party. Marcy tells her that she is nuts because there is no
way Marcy can afford a party since Sue has backed out of the deal. After some serious
negotiation Marcy and Sue settled their dispute with Sue agreeing to pay for half of
Marcy’s school loans and for all the expenses of Marcy’s upcoming wedding, and to
forget about Marcy throwing a party for her. Was there sufficient consideration to
support Marcy’s agreement to throw a party for Sue?