What happens when homeowners owe more to subcontractors than the total price they
were to pay the general contractor because the general contractor has not paid the
subcontractors and the general contractor is no longer solvent?
a. Homeowners are always exempt from paying more than they owed the general
contractor
b. The homeowners must pay the full amount due to all subcontractors
c. The homeowners cannot be liened by the subcontractors
d. Courts and states have differing standards of equity applied in resolving these issues
Zack Peyton borrowed $398,000 from Fifth First Bank to purchase a new home. Zack
gave First Bank a mortgage on his home. The mortgage was recorded on January 3,
2004. Zack had made a down payment of $42,000. When Zack moved in, he purchased
an in-ground swimming pool from Paddock Pools for $35,000. Zack paid Paddock
$4,000 and Paddock financed the remaining amount for him, recording a mortgage for
$29,000 on February 26, 2004. Zack needed window coverings, landscape, and some
new furniture. Wells Fargo gave Zack a $150,000 home equity line of credit, secured by
a mortgage on Zack’s home for $150,000. Wells Fargo recorded the home equity credit
line mortgage on February 1, 2004. Zack, because of a bonus at work, did not draw on
the line of credit until June 10, 2005, using $25,000.
The economy went south somewhere around September 2008. The value of Zack’s
home dropped by almost 50%. Zack lost his job. He could no longer make his
payments. Fifth First Bank served Zack with a notice of foreclosure on November 1,
2008.
Three months after Tommy bought Zack’s house at the foreclosure sale Zack is able to
find a job and received a signing bonus of $575,000. Zack wants his house back.
a. Because the sale has occurred and the transfer been made, Zack has no further rights
in the property