“Fighter.” Willy, a ninety-year-old wild bronco rider in the rodeo, had a will leaving all
his possessions to a girlfriend, Linda, age twenty-two. During a rodeo, Willy was placed
on a particularly wild bronco named “Fighter.” During the ride, Grumpy the clown
yelled out to Willy that Linda had suggested that particular horse. Willy was very
grumpy about that because he was having trouble controlling Fighter. Nevertheless,
Willy prevailed and collected the prize. Willy was so excited that he felt himself having
a heart attack. Just before he died, he yelled out, “Linda, you had me put on that crazy
horse, and I’m revoking my will. I’m dying, and I’m leaving everything to my other
girlfriend, Candy.” A number of witnesses heard his statement; and Grumpy, who had
always liked Candy more than Linda, promptly wrote down Willy’s statement. Linda
knew nothing about Candy and was very upset. She told Candy that Candy could have
nothing because Willy’s written will was still in effect. She also told Candy that Willy
was suffering from a mental illness and did not know what he was doing when he stated
that Candy should take everything. Willy’s daughter, Monique, age 65, also entered the
discussion stating that Linda had unfairly coerced Willy into writing a will leaving her
everything.
Which of the following is true regarding Monique’s claim that Linda unfairly coerced
Willy into naming her as a beneficiary in the written will and that the written will is
ineffective?
A. The written will is ineffective if Willy wrote it under circumstances by which Linda
took advantage of his weak physical or emotional condition to persuade him to write
the will leaving her everything.
B. The written will is ineffective only if a witness is available who will testify that
Willy admitted that he would never have left all his possessions to Linda if he were not
dependent on her for his wellbeing.
C. There is a presumption of undue influence based upon the age difference between
Linda and Willy.
D. Linda is legally entitled to a presumption of no undue influence because she was