“Check Cashing Business.” Susan owns and operates a check cashing business. A
regular customer, Bob, comes in and cashes a $2,000 check issued by ABC Trucking.
The day after Susan cashed the check, she received a notice from ABC Trucking that
some checks had been stolen. It was later discovered that the checks she cashed for Bob
had been stolen. At the time she took the check, Susan was very busy with several
customers in line. She simply glanced at the check and cashed it. A reasonable
examination would have revealed that the check had been materially altered and
changed from the amount of $200 to $2,000. Susan decided that she needed to hire
some people to help her because she also had a problem with another check. On the
same day that she took Bob’s check, she took a check from another customer, Maurice.
It was later discovered that the check, which was four months old, was the subject of a
dispute between Maurice and the issuer of the check for whom Maurice had done some
work. The issuer claimed that the work was improperly done. Both ABC Trucking and
the issuer of the check to Maurice had stopped payment on the checks. Susan claimed
that as a holder in due course, she was entitled to payment on both checks.
What is the effect of the alteration of the check on Susan’s status as a holder in due
course?
A. The alteration has no effect because a holder is not charged with examining an
instrument presented for payment.
B. The alteration will likely prohibit her from being a holder in due course.
C. The alteration will affect her status as a holder in due course only if she had been put
on notice of prior criminal behavior in the past on the part of Bob.
D. The alteration will affect her status as a holder in due course only if the issuer can
establish that it was not negligent in allowing a thief to gain access resulting in the
alteration.
E. On the basis that the law does not want to unduly burden holders, the alteration will
affect her status as a holder in due course only because the instrument was written for
an amount in excess of $500.