A van from Mario’s Squibb Company is damaged by a heavy metal keg, which rolls out
of the second floor window of the two storied Toss-Co. Flower building. Toss-Co.
Flower is the sole occupant of the building. Although the van was parked under the
window while making a delivery at the Toss Co. receiving dock, no one admits to
having seen the keg fall, nor are there any witnesses who can state where the keg was
just before the accident. Can Mario recover against Toss-Co. for negligence?
A. Mario can recover, but only if it proves in detail how Toss-Co. breached its duty of
reasonable care to Mario.
B. Mario can recover if it can prove that kegs do not fall out of windows in the absence
of negligence and that Toss-Co. had exclusive control of the keg prior to the accident.
C. Mario will be unable to recover because parking under an open second floor window
amounted to contributory negligence.
D. Mario will be unable to recover because parking under an open second floor window
amounted to assumption of risk.
Answer:
Lani is upset with her roommate Bill because he refuses to clean up after himself. In a
fit of rage, Lani tries to hit him on his head but misses. At the time, Bill is turned away
from Lani and is completely unaware that she tried to hit him. Under these
circumstances: