The Big Sale. Christy, the owner of ABC department store, needed to hire a number of
employees in a hurry because of a planned big summer sale. Bob was hired by Christy
to run a cash register and to assist customers with taking large purchases to their cars.
Bob encountered a particularly annoying customer, Frank. Frank started complaining
the minute he saw Bob. Frank complained about having to wait for Bob to assist him
with carrying his television purchase to his car, about the merchandise in the store, and
about the quality of the store’s employees. Bob tried to control himself while he carted
Frank’s television to the car. The final straw, however, came when Frank told Bob that
he should get the earring out of his ear, cut his hair, and act professionally. Bob threw
the television to the ground and punched Frank in the nose. Frank did investigation and
discovered that Bob has just been fired from his last three jobs for violent actions
against customers. Two of his former employers are willing to testify that if Christy had
called them, they would have disclosed Bob’s tendencies to her. Bob listed the former
employers on his application, but because she was in a hurry to hire employees, Christy
did not take the time to check with the former employers. Another problem confronting
Christy during the big sale is that Susie, a long-time employee of Christy who had
never caused any problem before, negligently dropped a box on the foot of Greg, a
customer. Greg had to have an X-ray and is threatening to sue both Christy and Susie.
Which of the following is true regarding whether Greg has any right of recovery against
Christy for his injured foot?
A. Greg has no right of recovery against Christy because Susie had not dropped any
boxes before, and Christy had no reason to suspect she would injure Greg.
B. Greg has a right of recovery against Christy only if Susie is insolvent.
C. Greg has a right of recovery against Christy, but only for 50% of his damages.
D. Greg has no right of recovery against Christy because he will not be able to establish
any wrongdoing on her part in hiring Susie.
E. Greg has a right of recovery against Christy.
Which of the following was the result on appeal in Fernando Tatis v. U.S. Bancorp, the
case in the text in which the plaintiff, a major-league baseball player, asked that the