Chapter 10A: Mutually Exclusive Investments Having Unequal Lives
$60,000 and would produce net cash flows of $25,000 for 5 years. Project B costs $100,000 and will produce annual net
cash flows of $25,000 for 10 years. If Lakeland’s cost of capital is 12%, which project should be chosen using the
equivalent annual annuity method?
Project A, as NPV is $17,941 higher
Project B, as NPV is $11,125 higher
Project A, as NPV is $28,383 higher
Project B, as NPV is $21,567 higher
6. Casa Chica is considering replacing a piece of equipment. Alternative A costs $80,000, has an eight year life and would
produce net cash flows of $18,000 in each of the eight years. Alternative B costs $65,000, has a six year life and would
produce net cash flows of $18,000 in each of the six years. If Chica’s cost of capital is 13%, which alternative should be
chosen using the equivalent annual annuity method?
Indifferent between the two projects
Neither, because both projects have a negative NPV
7. Toy Manufacturers (TM) is considering two mutually exclusive machines to use in its manufacturing process. The net
cash flows for each are given below:
If the cost of capital for TM is 13%, which machine should it purchase?
Beta, because it has the higher total net cash flows.
Beta, because it has the higher NPV.
Axa, because it has the higher NPV using infinite replacement.
Beta, because it has the higher NPV using infinite replacement.
8. Quorex is evaluating two mutually exclusive projects. Project A has a net investment of $48,000 and net cash flows
over a six-year period of $12,500 per year. Project B also has a net investment of $48,000, but its net cash flows of $8,640
per year will occur over a 12-year period. If Quorex has a cost of capital of 14% for these projects, which project, if either,
should be chosen, and what is its NPV?