Joe and Rich are both considering investing in a project with the following cash flows.
Joe is content earning a 9 percent return, but Rich desires a return of 16 percent. Who, if
either, should accept this project?
A. Joe, but not Rich
B. Rich, but not Joe
C. Neither Joe nor Rich
D. Both Joe and Rich
E. Joe, and possibly Rich, who will be neutral on this decision as his net present value
will equal zero
Swizer Industries has two separate divisions. Division X has less risk so its projects are
assigned a discount rate equal to the firms WACC minus 0.5 percent. Division Y has
more risk and its projects are assigned a rate equal to the firms WACC plus 1 percent.
The company has a debt-equity ratio of 0.45 and a tax rate of 35 percent. The cost of
equity is 14.7 percent and the aftertax cost of debt is 5.1 percent. Presently, each
division is considering a new project. Division Ys project provides a 12.3 percent rate
of return and Division Xs project provides an 11.64 percent return. Which projects, if
any, should the company accept?
A. Accept both X and Y
B. Accept X and reject Y
C. Reject X and accept Y
D. Reject both X and Y