A firm initially finances its assets with specified proportions of debt and equity, and
then later issues additional debt, using the proceeds to pay a dividend to shareholders. If
the new debt has the same priority as the original debt, the value of the original debt
will probably fall, an effect called claim dilution. Which of the assumptions of an ideal
capital market is violated in this example?
a. Capital Markets are frictionless
b. Homogeneous expectations
c. Atomistic competition
d. The firm has a fixed investment program
e. Once chosen, the firm’s financing is fixed
Joe Ogden, the Chairman and CEO of Ogdenergy, Inc., a promising venture in the
natural gas industry, is negotiating with Summer Street Capital Partners, a Buffalo,
NY-based venture capital firm (VC), for funding of $15 mn., which will be used for
building PP&E. Summer Street is impressed with the venture, and is considering
providing the funding in exchange for equity shares. However, Summer Street is
concerned that if they demand an equity ownership percentage that is too high,
Ogdenergy’s entrepreneurs may be less inclined to work hard to ensure the venture’s
success. They determine that if they demand a 40% equity percentage, the firm will be
worth $44 mn., but if they demand a 60% ownership percentage, the firm’s value will
be only $26 mn. Which equity ownership percentage should Summer Street take? (i.e.,
which maximizes Summer Street’s NPV?)
a. Summer Street should take a 40% equity percentage.
b. Summer Street should take a 60% equity percentage.