Opposing Views of Social Responsibility (Scenario)
The board of directors of the Four Forks Generating Corporation is meeting to consider
the construction of a new electrical generation facility near the Four Forks River.
Director Appleton prefers a coal-burning plant because it promises to be the most
profitable alternative. Over the short term at least, a coal plant will be by far the least
expensive facility to build and operate. Coal is cheap and the considerable pollution
from the plant won’t affect anything within hundreds of miles from the plant.
Director Estrella wants a nuclear plant to be located 30 miles upriver from the biggest
city in the area. Nuclear power is cleaner than coal. Completely safeguarding the
community against accidents in the plant or the disposal of toxic waste could be very
expensive. However, Estrella has discovered that the job can be done much more
cheaply by cutting some corners – while still strictly following all laws – and creating
some additional risk for the community.
Director Jossleman supports the most expensive option of the three – she wants a wind
farm to be built along the banks of the river on top of a ridge. The wind turbines
produce absolutely no pollution and pose no threat to the community or the
environment. They are expensive to build and to operate at the current time because
they require elaborate back-up systems to function when the wind isn’t blowing.
Director Appleton exhibits which of the following social responsibility views?
A) social responsiveness
B) broad view of social responsibility
C) classical view of social responsibility
D) socioeconomic view of social responsibility