An extra dollar of income to a poor person provides that person with less additional utility than does an extra
dollar to a rich person.
An extra dollar of income to a poor person provides that person with the same additional utility as does an
extra dollar to a rich person.
An extra dollar of income to a poor person provides that person with the same total utility as does an extra
dollar to a rich person.
30. Suppose society consists of three individuals: Phil, Jay, and Mitchell. Phil has $60,000 of income, Jay has $200,000 of
income, and Mitchell has $100,000 of income. A utilitarian would argue that
taking $1 from Mitchell and giving it to Phil would increase society’s total utility.
taking $1 from Mitchell and giving it to Jay would increase society’s total utility.
taking $1 from Phil and giving it to Jay would increase society’s total utility.
None of the above are correct because all three individuals have sufficient income.
31. Suppose society consists of four individuals: Andy, Bill, Carl, and David. Andy has $20,000 of income, Bill has
$40,000 of income, Carl has $60,000 of income, and David has $80,000 of income. A utilitarian would argue that
taking $1 from Bill and giving it to Carl would increase society’s total utility.
taking $1 from Carl and giving it to Andy would increase society’s total utility.
taking $1 from Carl and giving it to David would increase society’s total utility.
taking $1 from Bill and giving it to David would increase society’s total utility.
32. Which group (or groups) would be the most upset by wide variation in the income distribution?
utilitarians and liberals