In the case before her, Judge Thomas has heard claims by orange growers that to order a
stop to orange growing in order to control a pest that thrives on oranges plants but does
not harm them would result in a loss of profits of $3 million a year. The pest however
causes $2 million of damages to trees owned by pulp manufacturers. The orange
growers have not mentioned that they could control the pest at a cost of $1 million per
year. High transactions costs have prevented the parties from reaching a private
agreement. If she gives the property right to the
a. orange growers, they will then voluntarily control the pest.
b. orange growers, they will not control the pest.
c. pulp manufacturers, they will pay the orange growers to control the pest.
d. pulp manufacturers, the orange growers would offer a side payment of at least $2
million to be able to grow oranges.
Game Matrix V
The following questions refer to the game matrix below. Each firm has a choice of
saying Yes or NO. The profits each gets depend upon which it chooses.
. Which of the following values of X and Y result in the only Nash Equilibrium being
(No, No) and there also being a Prisoners’ Dilemma?
a. X = 21, Y = 9.
b. X = 19, Y = 11.