Recently, the secretary for the sales team has confided in you that Paul has been acting
inappropriately, and most recently, cornered her in the supply room, and pushed her up
against the wall with his body, and caressed her with his hands. She does not know that
you recommended Paul to the firm. Of the following choices, what should you do?
a. tell her not to worry, that it will pass, because Paul is not normally like this
b. tell her not to worry, that you’ll talk to Paul, and tell him to stop it
c. tell her to report Paul to Human Resources, and you’ll tell them you saw it
d. talk to Paul, and tell him that if he doesn’t stop it immediately, and apologize, you
will report him to Human Resources
19. Imagine that you are the judge hearing a case for sexual harassment filed by a woman
who reports that she was forced to have sex in the workplace with her supervisor. She
admits that for some months prior to the event, she displayed her body through seminude
photos, lifted her skirt to verify an absence of undergarments, made highly salacious
comments, and offered sexual gratification “to employees, customers, and competitors
alike.” Knowing what you know about harassment, what should you decide?
a. for the woman, because the forced sex proves harassment
b. for the woman, because her flirting did not justify the forced sex
c. for the employer, because the harassment was not unwelcome
d. for the employer, because she had a reputation for being “easy”
20. A male customer of a sports bar has taken a particular liking to one of the waitresses, and
always asks to be seated at her station, so that she will wait on him. He has spoken to the
manager of the bar, and generously tipped him to insure that he will get her station. But
the waitress does not want to wait on the customer, because he grabs and pinches her
rear, tries to tuck money down her top, and frequently pulls her down onto his lap. She
asks the bar manager not to let him sit at her station any more, but the manager tells her
it’s good money (he does tip her well), and she should be nice to him. If she files suit for
harassment, what will the court most likely rule?
a. for the employer, because the customer does not have the power to affect her
employment status, so that his conduct cannot result in a tangible employment
action against her
b. for the employer, because the customer has not committed harassment
c. for the employee, because the customer has committed harassment
d. for the employee, because the customer has committed harassment, the employer
knew about it, and did nothing
ESSAY QUESTIONS
1. Why is each of the following good legal advice?