that the law pertaining to more frequent inspections of larger restaurants should be upheld?
That under the rational basis test, inspections by the health department are needed in order to guard against
food-borne illnesses.
That under the strict scrutiny test, larger restaurants are important to the tax basis of the community and
should, therefore, be inspected more often to guard against illness and resulting lawsuits that could impact the
ability of the restaurants to remain in business.
That under the substantially related test, owners of larger restaurants should expect to be inspected more often
because products used in interstate commerce are invariably involved.
That under the common good test, large restaurants should be inspected more often in order to protect the
community’s tax base.
62. Refer to Fact Pattern 4-3. Under the Equal Protection clause, which of the following is the city’s best argument that the
law imposing a higher fee on female restaurant owners should be upheld?
That under the rational basis test, females should pay higher taxes so long as it can be shown that they have a
higher rate of business failure.
That under the intermediate level test, distinctions involving gender are examined in the same way as
distinctions based on guarantees in the Bill of Rights, and that the Bill of Rights allows gender-based
classifications.
That under the strict scrutiny test, gender is a legitimate method by which to delineate differences between
categories of citizens.
The city does not have a good argument because there is no justification for the distinction under the
substantially related test.
United States – BUSPROG: – ANALYTIC
63. The Tiny Motel is located in State X. It is not readily accessible from any major highway. Few, if any of their guests
are from out of state. The motel has filed suit in federal court to be exempt from the anti-discrimination provisions of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964. What are the arguments for and against exemption?
The Commerce Clause and whether interstate commerce is involved should be discussed.
There would likely be sufficient interstate commerce for the motel to be regulated by the
United States – BUSPROG: – ANALYTIC
64. State X has passed legislation to limit the amount of out–of-state widgets sold in the state. You are asked by an out–of–
a
Challenging
United States – BUSPROG: – ANALYTIC
DISC: – AICPA: BB-Legal
4-14 Equal Protection
Blooms: Analysis