5076 Income Inequality and Poverty
Scenario 20-1
The government is proposing switching from a progressive tax system in which families pay 15%
of the first $50,000 earned, 25% of the next $50,000 earned, and 35% of any income over
$100,000 to a tax system in which every family pays 20% of their income less $20,000.
67. Refer to Scenario 20-1. Which group would be most in favor of the switch from the current
progressive tax policy to the new policy?
a. Utilitarians, because they want to maximize the utility to the worst–off person in society
b. Liberals, because of the maximin criterion
c. Libertarians, because they believe in diminishing marginal utility
d. All three groups would be equally in favor of the switch.
68. Refer to Scenario 20–1. What would the libertarians think of the proposed policy change?
a. They would favor the current progressive policy over the proposed policy because it accounts
for diminishing marginal utility.
b. They would favor the proposed tax policy over the current progressive policy because it would
result in a negative tax for the poorest families.
c. They would favor the current progressive tax policy over the proposed policy because it
rewards those who work the hardest.
d. They would oppose both tax policies because both redistribute income.