15.7 Scenario-Based Questions
Read the following scenario and answer the questions below.
Under the Kyoto Protocol, developed countries promised to cut their greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions below their respective 1990 emissions by 2102. Canada’s promise was to cut the
GHGs 6% below its 1990 emissions of 592 Mt (of CO2 eq). In the years after signing the Kyoto
Protocol, the Liberal governments talked about Kyoto, but did little to effect the necessary
reductions in our emissions. In 2006, a Conservative government led by Stephen Harper was
elected, and it effectively abandoned the Kyoto target, arguing that it is unreasonable: the
Conservatives criticized Kyoto for not setting targets for China, a country with rapidly increasing
emissions, while setting one for Canada, a country that produces only 2% of global emissions.
The Conservatives also argued that the Kyoto reductions are unfair to Canada, because we are a
large and cold country, and as such, we need to use more energy for transportation and heating
than other countries. By 2008 our emissions were at 734 Mt (of CO2 eq), that is 24% above the
1990 level, in a large part a result of the increased emissions from tar sands and other large
industrial projects. Rather than admitting the failure to live up to our obligations, Canada became
the first country to withdraw from the Kyoto Protocol and encouraged others to follow suit.
During earlier climate talks, Canada has became known for its efforts to block the progress of the
other countries toward a global solution for climate change, opting instead to protect the interests
of the fossil fuel industry. In place of the Kyoto target, the Harper government in 2010 set itself
another target: a 17% reduction from 2005 emissions of 731 Mt (of CO2 eq.) by 2020. In 2012
Environment Commissioner Scott Vaughan reported to the House of Commons that “the
reductions are not happening fast enough to meet the 2020 target.”
1) Which of the following is NOT true about the Stephen Harper government’s greenhouse
emissions plan?
A) Under this plan we will emit in 2020 more than we emitted in 1990.
B) The plan will deliver smaller reductions than promised under Kyoto.
C) Canada pulls its weight, because the new targets are in line with the commitments of other
industrialized countries.
D) The plan will take a longer period to achieve less than what was set out in the Kyoto
obligations.
E) The government is not likely to meet even its reduced and delayed target.