ESSAY. Write your answer in the space provided or on a separate sheet of paper.
Falsifying Scientific Theories: In many simple expositions of the scientific method, it is often stated that if a
scientific theory makes an incorrect prediction, it is falsified and must be discarded. Argue against this simple
view of the scientific method by using the Algol paradox (Section 13.4) as a case study. In particular, why did
astronomers not discard the theory of stellar evolution despite an apparent direct contradiction of a
fundamental prediction of stellar evolution, that more massive stars evolve faster than less massive stars?
Stellar Evolution as a Scientific Theory: Based on the chapter material, list what you feel are the basic founding
assumptions of the theory of stellar evolution. For example, you might list that stars are assumed to be balls of
mostly hydrogen gas held together by their own gravity. After this, make another list of as many of the
successful predictions of this theory as you can. Based on the comparison of these two lists, how successful a
scientific theory would you rate the theory of stellar evolution?
Historical Supernova: You find an ancient Chinese text that speaks of a “new star” briefly visible in the
constellation Sagittarius in the year 1000 B.C. You suspect that the reference is to a supernova explosion. Design
an observing program to provide scientific evidence for this hypothesis. What object or objects would you look
for in the sky today? What wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation would you use? How would you be sure
any object you found exploded (as seen from the Earth) nearly 3000 years ago?
The Faintest White Dwarfs: All low–mass stars end their lives by forming white dwarfs which evolve by cooling
at a constant radius, growing less and less luminous with time. You are about to begin an observing program to
look for the faintest white dwarfs in the Milky Way Galaxy. In the course of your observations, will you
continue to find white dwarfs that are less and less luminous, or will you ultimately find a population of white
dwarfs that are the least luminous ones in the Milky Way? If you answer the latter, what is your interpretation
of this result?
The birth place of stars: Discuss the observational evidence that supports the idea that most stars are formed in
groups from large clouds of interstellar gas and dust.