109) Sometimes geographers, public officials, and market analysts are so involved with
questions of “how” to enact changes that we don’t pause enough to ask “why” or “whether we
should” aid specific types of developments in a city or neighborhood. In actuality, controversies
abound over urban transitions, gentrification, and plans involving new construction. Go online to
search for recent media coverage of controversial changes in your city or community, and ask
professors and fellow students about the ethical dimensions of those changes. What changes have
most residents been concerned about? What alternative plans have been proposed?
110) Rather than simply asking “how” to enact changes we should pause to ask “why” or
“whether we should” make specific kinds of changes in our communities. For example,
controversies abound over urban transitions, gentrification, and plans involving the construction
of new Walmart stores. Search for this kind of news coverage concerning a nearby community,
list some of the “pros” in favor of opening a new Walmart, and then discuss several of the “cons”
against the building of these stores. You should also speak with classmates, professors, and
community activists and evaluate their arguments concerning low wages, anti-union policies, and
the closing of smaller stores when a new Walmart arrives.
111) Given our concerns about the underclass, homelessness, ethnic and racial segregation, and
other problems in society today, invent a set of ethical guidelines that you believe that
geographers should follow in their work. Be as specific as possible, and use evidence from the
textbook to reinforce the ethical frameworks that you create.