Case 7-1
Jack was arrested for the serious crime of robbery by the local police department. When
police searched Jack incident to arrest, they found a small amount of heroin and a
needle used for injecting heroin. Jack is also homeless. He has no family and no means
to support himself, except committing crime. He commits crime in order to support his
drug habit.
Jack is concerned that because he cannot afford a high-priced criminal defense attorney,
he will not have a chance in his trial. Which of the following statements summarizes the
effectiveness of publicly funded counsel compared to private counsel?
a. Conviction rates of defendants with private counsel are lower than those represented
by publicly funded attorneys.
b. Conviction rates of defendants with private counsel are higher than those represented
by publicly funded attorneys.
c. Conviction rates of defendants with private counsel and those represented by publicly
funded attorneys are generally the same.
d. A higher percentage of defendants with public defenders are placed on probation.
Case 14-1
Bobby was born and raised in the United States. At the age of 16 he converted from
Christianity to become a Muslim. At first his parents were not concerned as they wanted
him to practice the religion of his choice. After Bobby returned home from a trip to the
Middle East, his parents became very concerned about his extreme religious beliefs.
Bobby’s parents went through his belongings, including his computer, when he was
meeting with his religious advisors one evening. They became alarmed because they
found bomb-making training manuals and communications with people in the Middle
East who appeared to be terrorists.