18 UNIT SEVEN: PROPERTY AND ITS PROTECTION
ESSAY QUESTIONS
1. During a storm on Blue Lake, a boat sinks, but its owner Cappy survives.
Cappy plans to return to the site of wreck to salvage its equipment and his
possessions, but he delays. Meanwhile, Dick, an amateur diver, discovers the
wreck and strips it clean of useful items. Cappy learns of the recovery and files
a suit against Dick, claiming that the items are his. Dick responds that the
sunken boat was abandoned and therefore he has good title to everything to
which he took possession. What is the court likely to rule, and why?
2. French’s Fast Fries (3F) requires that its employees wear uniforms and
protective clothing while on the job. 3F provides a locker room for the
employees to leave their street clothes and personal items while working. A
sign on the back of the locker room door states, “French’s is not responsible for
the loss of any property in the locker room.” Grant, a 3F employee, changes his
clothes in the locker room before starting work and leaves his wallet and watch
in a pocket of his jacket hanging in his locker. When he returns after his shift,
the wallet and watch are gone. Does Grant’s leaving personal items in the
locker room constitute a bailment? If so, what type of bailment? If not, what
legal relationship is it? Does 3F’s sign exculpate the company for Grant’s loss?
Why or why not?